This “intellectual journey” has an underlying history. The author came to this task while working in the Criminal Justice System of Nigeria (CJS), namely, the Nigeria Prison Service, between 1999 and 2003. Those five years were full of experiences and problem-solving scenarios from prison inmates who had either been detained or convicted. The police who arrested and sent them to prison labelled the majority of them “armed robbers”, pending the court hearings, which did not come up as and when due. With the daily influx of armed robbery suspects in prison, the author thought it wise to study this subject area to understand the probable factors responsible for the youthful involvement in “armed robbery”, and to suggest crime prevention and/or reduction strategies, which may help the government and criminologists in criminal justice policy-making.
The current study was originally intended to be a comparative study of armed robbery in Nigeria and Britain (or more precisely England). Comparative criminology dates back to the time of Emile Durkheim (Newman & Howard, 2001). It involves an evaluative study of any type of crime as it affects more than one culture, or one nation-state, or region. The value of comparative criminology is that it identifies an interesting subject area for study as well as an important method of carrying out the research (Zimring & Johnson, 2005).
Armed robbery is an important subject that has been studied widely by criminologists across the world. Research began to develop in the second half of the twentieth century. De Baun (1950); McClintock & Gibson (1961); Normandeau (1968a, 1968b, 1968c, 1969a, 1969b), and Einstadter (1969) for example, pioneered the study of armed robbery in both the US and the UK. Since then many studies have featured samples from national, cultural, cross-cultural or cross-national populations (see for example Rotimi, 1984; Nkpa, 1976; Marenin, 1987; Ekpenyong, 1989; Otu, 2003;
Desroches, 1995, 2002; O’Donnell & Morrison, 1994; Matthews, 1996; Matthews et
al, 2001; Matthews, 2002; Gill, 2000, 2001; Wright et al, 2006; Wright & Decker,
1987; Macdonald, 1975; Gabor et al, 1987; Wright & Decker, 1997; Cook, 1987; Conklin, 1972; Nugent et al, 1989; Smith & Louis, 2010; Borycki, 2003; Borycki et al, 2005).
Armed robbery being talked about in this study involves banks, shops, petrol stations, domestic houses and highways or motorways. It involves different levels of force and an array of different weapons (Matthews, 2002) such as guns and knives. Matthews (2002) has also suggested that in some armed robberies enacted in the UK, weapons were not used at all. This is not the case in Nigeria, because those who get involved use weapon(s) to threaten, force and deprive a person or persons of the right to private, public or corporate belongings (Nwalozie, 2007). Based on the different notions of the umbrella term “armed robbery” in Nigeria and the UK, it has become too general a concept to use as a starting point of analysis (Matthews, 2002). Although armed robbery is a serious offence committed by youths, our interest is not so much in the terminology “armed robbery” but we are much more concerned with understanding what motivates them to do it. However, for the sake of clarity and writing conventions used herein, the terms robbery and/or armed robbery will refer to the same subject matter, “armed robbery”. If for any reason a different type of robbery is mentioned, it will be clearly stated.
The initial intention to do a comparative research of armed robbery in Nigeria and Britain was for obvious reasons: To date, neither Nigerian nor British scholars have carried out any comparative study of armed robbery between both countries. The absence of cross-national or cross-cultural research on armed robbery in the two states has created a gap in the literature. There is a colonial legacy that makes this interesting, the British leaving a legal system in the post colonial period and how suited or unsuited such a system is to contemporary Nigeria in the comparative study of crime and criminal justice. It seems also that Nigerian criminologists are not so inclined to comparative studies due to financial constraints and access to research data, while British criminologists seem to be more inclined to comparing crime and criminal justice among the developed countries in Europe and America where financial resources and access to research data may not be so problematic.
So, doing a comparative study of armed robbery in Nigeria and Britain would probably have been the first of its kind; it would also have generated new knowledge in criminological science. Particularly, we would have come to know in more details
the similarities and differences surrounding the nature and patterns of armed robbery in the two countries. Presumably any comparative research in criminology must highlight the similarities and dissimilarities of a particular crime in the countries being studied. Our first concern would have been to establish whether armed robbery was a problem in both countries (see Clinard & Abbot, 1973). The research would have considered two different groups of youths from two different cultural backgrounds. The study would have enabled us to know the current, recent, and previous robbery trends in both countries. This would have involved comparing crime rates from police data and interviews with participants. Moreover, we would have come to know if the motivations to robbery are either similar or different or both. Motivation to crime is arguably the most assumed, causal variable in the origin of criminal behaviour. Indeed no offence can be committed without the offender being motivated by some factor(s) (Jacobs & Richards, 1999: 149).
Outside the comparative realm, it would probably be difficult to properly determine which underlying factors could be criminogenic (Neapolitan, 2003) in both countries. It was therefore essential to ascertain if similar social processes would be responsible for crime in a technologically advanced country [Britain] and a developing country [Nigeria] (Clinard & Abbott, 1973: 1). Our task would have been to test if certain criminological theories applicable to Britain could also be applicable to Nigeria. If the results turned out to be similar, they would strengthen our confidence in universal findings and theories. If on the contrary differences emerged, the challenge would be to explain the differences, perhaps by reference to features of national contexts (Farrington, 1999). However, it is the goal of any comparative criminology to develop concepts and generalisations at a level that distinguishes universals that apply to every society and unique characteristics that can be found in one or few places (Bendix, 1963). Finally, we would have explored the preventive and/or reductive measures put in place by the Criminal Justice Systems of both countries and suggested ways forward.
With that in mind, the author set about researching relevant literature on comparative criminology; and even wrote a chapter on that area. His interest was more in robbery trajectories in both Nigeria and Britain in relation to their political economies. However, the researcher tried to explore a few other countries such as the United
States of America, Australia and Canada to make the comparison robust. The literature review was undertaken earlier with the hope that access would be granted the researcher to conduct his research in both Nigeria and Britain.
Within eight months, access was granted the researcher to interview prisoners in Nigeria; but unfortunately, access was denied him in England after twelve months of making four separate applications to four prisons in that country. This experience calls to mind that while prison establishments across the world deal with those who have gone contrary to the criminal law of a particular country, the demands of the different jurisdictions regarding security and research materials acceptable to prison regimes are quite different too. For example, the researcher has come to know that while a laptop, memory stick and tape recorder may be allowed for academic research in a Nigerian prison, they may not be approved for such in an English prison.
Considering all these daunting experiences and obvious setbacks, and with the full support of his supervisors, the researcher decided to conduct a “single study” by focusing on Nigeria where he was granted access to interview young armed robbers in Kirikiri Maximum Security Prison in Lagos. The next challenge was to restructure the thesis by discarding the written chapters on comparative criminology and the political economy of Britain. This experience has revealed that while a researcher may set out to do a particular research of his choice, he may end up doing what he never wanted to do.
Nevertheless, in the context of the current thesis, it is important to stress that occasions may warrant comparative literature, survey data and official crime statistics from some parts of the world, especially Africa being employed to make the study more robust. Comparing recorded crime between different jurisdictions can create complications (Barclay & Tavares, 2000). It has been argued on the other hand, that official statistics contain many problems and errors that seriously constrain their use for comparative study (Lynch 1993; Mayhew & Van Dijk, 1997).
In trying to conduct this study, the researcher reflected on the theoretical framework that would be suitable for the explanation of criminal behaviour, particularly armed robbery in Nigeria. The theory that captured the researcher’s imagination and interest more than any other was subcultural theory, from which the title of the thesis was formulated. At the beginning of the interviews, respondents seemed to be young men
robbing people, however, the researcher thought the study had some kind of resonance around subcultural form.
One of the assumptions about “subculture” is the lower, subordinate, or deviant status of social groups labelled as such. These labelled groupings are distinguised by their class, ethnicity, language, poor and working class situations (Cutler, 2006); age or generation (Maira, 1999). These cultural and socio-structural variables make subcultures relatively homogeneous (Epstein, 2002).
Since the 1990s, the term subculture has been used in a much broader perspective to explain any group of people who adjust to norms of behaviour, values, beliefs, consumption patterns, and lifestyle choices that are distinct from those of the dominant mainstream culture (Cutler, 2006). According to Gelder (2005: 1):
Subcultures are groups of people that are in some way represented as non-normative and/or marginal through their particular interests and practices, through what they are, what they do, and where they do it. They may represent themselves in this way; since subcultures are usually aware of their differences, bemoaning them, relishing them, exploiting them, and so on. But they will also be represented like this by others, who in response can bring an entire apparatus of social classification and regulation to bear upon them.
Gelder’s definition takes into account the groups themselves on the one hand; and mainstream society on the other. The groups feel marginalized because of their life situation, hence they decide to exhibit negative behaviour. Gelder also reveals how the entire society views these groups, and especially the way they categorize and isolate them as “subcultures”. Yet subcultures share elements of the main culture, while at the same time distinct from it (Brake, 1987: 6).
In the generic sense, the term subculture could be applied to any group of individuals whose behaviour differs from the rest of society. For example, we hear about occupational subculture (Trice, 1993); religious subculture (Gay & Ellison, 1993); consumer subculture (Schouten & Mcalexander, 1995); drug subculture (Cutler, 2006; Cohen & Sas, 1994), immigrant subculture (Brake, 1987); internet or cybercrime subculture (Adeniran, 2008; Kahn & Kellner, 2006), and so on. This wider description of subculture has come to the attention of some scholars (Weinzierl & Muggleton,
2006; Cutler, 2006) who query its utility, hence their call for a reconceptualisation or replacement of the term. It is argued that this new conceptualisation captures the changing sensibilities and practices of subcultural forms (Weinzierl & Muggleton, 2006) in relation to youth groups.
Youth groups are now being referred to as “channels or subchannels”; “temporary substream networks”; “neo-tribes” and “clubculture” (see Weinzierl & Muggleton, 2006). While this reconceptualisation project does not receive the outright approval of scholars like Hodkinson (2002), it is apparent that some of these confusions can be clarified if we recognise that different concepts are often used to abstract varied aspects of social reality, and that they can be used interchangeably with subculture to refer to a variety of youth cultural formations (see Weinzierl & Muggleton, 2006). Therefore, a reconceptualised idea of subculture must have “relative distinctiveness”, provide a sense of “identity”, a level of “commitment”, and the relative “autonomy” to operate (see Hall & Jefferson, 2006; Hodkinson, 2002).
For more than half a century, subcultural theory has increasingly influenced the study of youth crime (Young, 2010). In doing so, it has developed two waves on the two sides of the Atlantic - a liberal or structural-functionalist American current of the 1950s and 1960s; and a Marxist British version of the late 1970s (see Young, 2010; Newburn, 2007; Blackman, 2005). The former started at the Chicago School, while the latter originated from the Birmingham Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies, University of Birmingham (CCCS).
The Chicago School first used the concept “subculture” in their explanation of delinquency (see for example Cohen, 1955; Miller, 1958; Cloward & Ohlin, 1960). Cohen (1955) went as far as developing Merton’s anomic propositions in his seminal work, Delinquent Boys. He argued that a large group of male adolescents had developed a culture, with its norms, values, and expectations contrary to the dominant culture. This subculture emerged when youths from lower socio-economic status families struggled to achieve success. When compared to youths from middle class society, those from the lower class had disadvantaged academic backgrounds. Their inability to achieve success brought about their involvement in a subculture where they could find success and status enhancement. So, this subculture refused middle
class values such as academic achievement, courtesy and delayed gratification (see also Nihart et al, 2005). Cohen concludes that this delinquent subculture is “non- utilitarian”, “malicious” and “negativistic” (Cohen, 1955: 25) because it is used by status-frustrated youths as a hit-back mechanism (Macdonald, 2001: 33). Therefore, from the point of view of the youths themselves, their conduct is to be considered as meaningful (see Clubb, 2001).
Miller (1958) further developed the work of Cohen by identifying what he refers to as “focal concerns” of the lower class culture. He uses “focal concerns” in preference to “value”; and they include: trouble, toughness, smartness, excitement, fate and autonomy. Apparently, the “focal concerns” are a reflection of working class traditions rather than working class frustrations (see also Macdonald, 2001: 34). For Miller, middle-class norms and values are not subculturally relevant. What is relevant, he argues, is that members of the subculture conform to the distinctive value system of their own working class culture (see also Macdonald, 2001: 33). This implies that people’s circumstances in life may push them to adopt certain measures or patterns of behaviour, which may be beneficial or not. Miller put this question: why is the commission of crimes a customary feature of gangs? His answer is: street youths are motivated to commit crime by the desire to achieve ends, status, or conditions which are valued, and to avoid those that are disvalued within their most meaningful cultural milieu, through those culturally available avenues which appear as the most feasible means of achieving those ends (Miller, 1958: 17).
Cloward and Ohlin (1960) improved on the groundwork established by both Cohen and Miller, namely the kind of environment that gave rise to delinquent youths (see also Nihart et al, 2005). As Cloward and Ohlin (1960: 86) maintain, adolescents who form delinquent subcultures, have internalized an emphasis upon conformist goals. Drawing on Merton’s (1938) anomie-strain theory and Shaw and Mckay’s (1942) social disorganisation theory, Cloward and Ohlin argued that lower class boys were faced with inadequacies of lawful avenues of access to these goals and unable to revise their ambitions downward, they experienced severe disappointments, hence their involvement in higher levels of delinquency than middle and upper class youths (see also Nihart et al, 2005). Thus, unfavourable and disappointing expectation in life
could determine delinquent behaviour as a viable option. Cloward and Ohlin outlined three typologies of deviant subculture namely: criminal, conflict, and retreatist.
Like the Chicago School, the early Birmingham School focused on the link between the “deviant” sensibilities of youth “gangs” and the localities from which such gangs emerged (Bennett, 1999). Ecological studies of various parts of post-war Britain1 found poverty as the main cause of delinquency, especially when combined with the absence of the father figure. In the 1950s, the absent or working mother came in for criticism. Child-rearing practices were compared, and working class life was seen as divided into “the rough” and “the respectable”. Delinquency was found to have local traditions and values in underprivileged areas of Liverpool and London (see Brake, 1987: 59).
With the publication of the CCCS research, British studies of youth culture experienced two fundamental changes. Firstly, emphasis shifted from the study of youth gangs to style-based youth cultures, such as Teddy boys, Mods, Rockers and Skinheads, which from the 1950s onwards rapidly became an essential feature of everyday British social life. Secondly, in keeping with the central hypothesis of the CCCS, as noted above, the “local” focus of earlier youth studies was given up completely in favour of a subcultural model of explanation (Bennett, 1999). The initial Chicago School’s premise that subcultures are critical to an understanding of deviance as normal behaviour in the face of particular social circumstances was reworked by the Birmingham School in their most influential work, Resistance Through Rituals (1976), in order to account for the style-centred youth cultures of post-war Britain. According to the CCCS, the deviant behaviour of such youth “subcultures” had to be understood as the collective reaction of youths themselves, or rather working-class youths, to structural changes taking place in British post-war society (Bennett, 1999).
In his assessment of the two subcultural waves mentioned above, Cohen (1980: vi)said: “Both work with the same “problematic” ... growing up in a class society; bothidentifythesamevulnerablegroup:theurbanmaleworking-classlateadolescent;
1Thanks to scholars like Mays (1954); Morris (1957); Kerr (1958) for conducting such studies.
both see delinquency as a collective solution to a structurally imposed problem”. This “problematic” is probably different from the Nigerian situation because of the tribal divide of the youth population, but we shall see that some unemployed working class Nigerian youths still face collective problems that need redress such as bad friends, lack of money, poverty, corruption, and so on.
Again, and as we shall see later, the youth respondents for this study are from different tribes in the country (see table 18), even though the group element in their criminal behaviour is not in doubt. However, as the fieldwork progressed, it became apparent that it was not a subcultural form. Even so, the author thought that subcultural theory and its forms might still work; but disappointingly, the cultural identities (such as common language, code of dressing, and music) shared by popular subcultural groups like Teddy boys, Punks, Hip hops, were not found among the youths chosen for this Nigerian study. Arguably, the sample of respondents (armed robbers) were doing something very different from what could be termed a subculture. So, as the data was analyzed, it became obvious that the subculture paradigm would not work.
Nevertheless, subcultural theorists have always insisted that they are better placed to explain criminal behaviour (Blackman, 2005), hence no study of youth delinquency can easily be undertaken without recourse to many of their insights (Newburn, 2007). This is because subcultural theorists tend to consider the general nature of delinquency with an emphasis on youth gangs and groups instead of the individual deviant (Newburn, 2007). Thus, they place the group in the context of the entire society (see Young, 2010). According to Cohen (1955: 178), delinquency is not about something individualistic, but refers to “gangs of boys doing things together, their actions deriving their meaning and flavour from the fact of togetherness and governed by a set of common understanding, common sentiments and common loyalties” (cited in Gelder, 2005: 21). To be involved in group delinquency also implies that the individual takes delight and relief in the protective and sympathetic comfort of the group as he shares his experience of facing common tasks with them (Walsh, 1986).
Contemporary criminologists have invoked the principles of subcultural theorisation in their various studies of youthful offending, including armed robbery. For example,
Jacobs and Wright (1999) interviewed 86 active armed robbers in St Louis Missouri (USA), on the impact of “street culture” on an offender’s decision to engage in armed robbery. They conclude that “street culture subsumes a number of powerful conduct norms, including but not limited to the hedonistic pursuit of sensory stimulation, disdain for conventional living, lack of future orientation, and persistent eschewal of responsibility” (Jacobs & Wright, 1999: 165). This implies that those associated with street lifestyles are averse to the conventional norms of mainstream society. It is this aversion to the norms of mainstream society that makes them become a deviant subculture. However, not all subcultures are deviant or criminal-oriented (but see Cohen & Sas, 1994).
In what follows, the subcultural approach is not immune from criticisms. To begin with, the notion of subculture has never really been adequately defined. Even when definitions are attempted, they are generically driven and without any connection with youth delinquency, which the concept purports to be addressing. As Bennett (1999: 599) stresses, “the problems of using ‘subculture’ is that it has sometimes been applied inexactly, becoming little more than a convenient ‘catch-all’ term for any aspect of social life in which young people, style and music intersect”. It is little wonder that “subculture” has been used as an ad hoc concept whenever a writer wished to emphasize the normative aspects of behaviour contrary to some general standard. The result has been a blurring of the meaning of the term, confusion with other terms, and a failure frequently to distinguish between two levels of social causation (see Yinger, 1960: 625-6 cited in Jenks, 2005: 7). Moreover, one would question the random use of the term “subculture” to apply to those who live oppositional to the mainstream society as those who have no positive ideals to pursue, thus making them all the more isolated from the larger society. On this view, their marginalization is simply intensified by their designation as a “subculture” (Jenks, 2005: 130).
Subcultural theory fails to make a clear-cut distinction between “subcultures” and “gangs”. Every so often, it tries to merge the two together in the name of studying deviant criminal groups. For example, Walsh (1986: 19) makes this merger by arguing that the concept of “gang” and “subculture” are conventionally used to explain the cultural enclave in which the apprenticeship process occurs, stressing
group support, both physical and in the sense of shared guilt or blame after events. In doing so, he begs the question about the authenticity of the so-called “subcultures”. It is important to stress that both concepts are different. Gangs are informally-structured “near groups” made up of a closely connected core with a looser network of peripheral members; whereas subcultures are the cluster of actions, values, style, imagery and lifestyles which through media reportage, extend beyond a neighbourhood to form a complex relationship with other larger cultures to form a symbolic pseudo-community (Brake, 1987). This distinction is important if we are to avoid the misrepresention of subculture as almost anything any person may think of. Otherwise, looking at the formal and substantive elements of “subculture”, if the term were to be introduced for the first time now, it would be dismissed as inadequate (Clark 1974 cited in Brake, 1987).
The subcultural approach is notoriously “overly deterministic” in its emphasis on the “peer group” or “gangs” or rather “group criminality”; but it is silent about the place of “personal choice” and “free will” in criminal behaviour (Clubb, 2001). Being in a subculture or gang makes delinquent activity more likely by actively promoting it, nevertheless, this does not make deviant behaviour obligatory. The individual is naturally free to choose whether to commit a crime or not, and to do so for personal reasons rather that as a group requirement (Clubb, 2001; Williams, 1997). Crime causation is a matter for the individual to deal with without much concern for the group (Clubb, 2001). This has also been a favourable argument for Merton’s anomie theory. However, according to Sutherland and Cressey’s differential association theory (1978), the values which encourage peers to commit crime are learnt alongside the techniques to commit crime. When peers behave contrary to the group, they break away from the group’s solidarity. Group solidarity is a formidable and pivotal force as far as the subculture is concerned. Arguably, most youth crimes would not be committed in a group if people did not want to exhibit their popularity and status among their members. Therefore being overly deterministic is a subcultural “complacency” to perpetuate criminal behaviour among youths.
The claim of subcultural theorists to be better placed in the study of youth delinquency is overexaggerated. While they have a role in explaining group delinquency, they are deficient in the understanding of individual criminality. Group
criminality presupposes individual criminality, which likely starts at home before it degenerates into peer delinquency in the form of a subculture.
The issue of a group’s homogeneity makes subcultural formation utterly “selective” and pro-western. Arguably, it is unnecessary to look for a homogeneous youth criminal population in order to group them into a subcultural form. Youths of different age brackets and backgrounds can still come together to form a subculture in order to address what they perceive as youth problems in the polity.
Moreover, subcultural theory has consistently been attacked for having only one vulnerable group of people in mind, that is urban male working class late adolescents (see for example Macdonald, 2001). This position of criminologists from both sides of the Atlantic has overdominated subcultural studies with a stereotype of the youthful offender. An all-important question is: why has a particular group of individuals remained the focus of subcultural theorists as those that can be associated with delinquency? Subcultural theorists should make a leap and extend their studies to various groups of youths in post-modern society in order to understand the dynamics of youth delinquency. Criminologists from Africa must now rise to the challenge of creating their own school of subcultural studies instead of depending on the sort of “benchmark” set by both the Chicago and Birmingham Schools as the measure for subcultural studies.
Scholars (Redhead, 1990; Melechi, 1993; Miles, 1995; Malbond, 1998; Muggleton, 1997; Bennett, 2000) have argued that subcultures were created by subcultural theorists, not vice versa. That is to say, subcultural theorists determine what subcultures should represent. For instance, American theorists would answer the question about the delinquent by referring to the “delinquent subculture” involving coded honours based on “Rep” and the mobilisation of violence (Young, 2010). British theorists would talk about the Teds, Punks, Mods, and so on, by clearly defining their styles, thereby ignoring the lack of clarity of the actors involved (Young, 2010). In this sense, subcultural theory may be accused of being over- dominated by Western criminologists, especially American and British scholars, to an extent that any study of youth subcultures elsewhere must be influenced by studies from either or both countries. The danger is that subcultural theorists from both sides
of the Atlantic end up glamorising delinquents by “popularising” them as Rep, Mods, Teds, Hip hops etc, with the end result that the criminal behaviours of youth subcultures are downplayed.
Subcultures are male-dominated so much so that an emphasis on “maleness” is seen as a panacea for an identity that has been weakened by structural features (Brake, 1987). Perhaps the invisibility of girls’ subculture is because the very term “subculture” has acquired such consistently masculine overtones (McRobbie and Garber, 2005). In this connection, men are regarded as more criminally-minded than women. It has been argued that the “absence of girls from the whole of literature in this area is quite striking and demands explanation” (McRobbie & Garber, 1976: 209), and very little seems to have been written about the involvement of girls in group delinquency (McRobbie and Garber, 2005); but whenever they are acknowledged in the literature, the focus has been on their sexual attractiveness. If subcultural theorists neglect the holistic study of female group delinquency, then a crucial element of research that can explore the gender divide in offending is lacking.
Subcultural theory has been accused of over-prediction with regard to delinquency. For example, among the poorest working class communities, crime is not ever-present in all individuals (see Newburn, 2007). Critics also maintain that subcultural theory is unnecessarily over-rational in an attempt to grant human actors a sense of making their history in a determinate world. Consequent to that is an unreflective bouncing off the conditions that beset such people (Young, 2010) hence the freedom to drift (Matza, 1964) into crime. For instance, the robber continues to rob, the alcoholic continues to drink and get drunk (see Young, 2010). In doing so, a culture of crime is developed and animated.
Subcultural theorisation tends to split up a whole society when it talks about “deviants”, thus suggesting that there are also non-deviants. This makes the deviants to claim a moral high ground for their actions, while at the same time finding faults with the mainstream society. Arguably, for the deviant, the mainstream is seen as deviant; while for the mainstream, the subculture is the deviant. In the words of Jenks (2005: 129) “the idea of subculture can be employed to valorise the underdog,
radicalize the dispossesed, give voice to the inarticulate but equally to marginalize and contain the deviant or non-mainstream”.
However, if by subculture we are referring to the well-known theory of the 1950s and 1970s, then it might not be feasible to employ it in the explanation of the “youth subculture” who enact armed robberies in Nigeria. As noted before, this is largely due to the absence in this study of cultural identities associated with subcultures, such as dress code, music, common language, and so on. Although these cultural identities may be crucial to any subcultural formation, they seem to have been overemphasized by the theory, thereby overshadowing the study of criminal behaviour of youth subcultures. In addition, the characteristics of the offender sample in the present study in terms of age, state of origin, tribe, and geo-political zone do not fit with the homogeneous nature of subculture, even though the respondents are involved in group criminality, which subcultural theorists claim to be better positioned to explain (see once again Blackman, 2005).
Even if subculture remains the best way to explain more unconventional aspects of youth culture, it does not seem to offer much help for an understanding of the wide range of youth groups in the post-modern world (Cutler, 2006; Muggleton & Weinnzierl, 2006). This may be because of the way subculture is somewhat “benchmarked” to refer to certain group of people alone. In that weakness, subcultural theory has probably now, “run its course” (Jenks 2005: 145), become “superfluous” and “no longer relevant” (Chaney 2004: 36) and fails to provide “a useful description of young people’s social world or their experiences” (Karvonen et al, 2001: 393) in relation to the crime of armed robbery in Nigeria.
It is important to reiterate that youth involvement in criminality there arises from the injustices of the Nigerian state: when youths come together as “bad friends” to carry out armed robbery, they are motivated by a desire to get money due to the poverty and endemic corruption in the country. These are their major kinds of indicators that explain what they do. One can see their reasons as either appropriate or not. To say that they are fighting against the state appears to be a romanticisation of crime, given that it would be open to them to do so by peaceful protest or demonstration.
Since subcultural theory could not bear on this study as its theoretical framework, and there is no Nigerian criminological theoretical framework to help us, the available option was to employ anomie-strain theory and a measure of control theory because the data (see chapter 5) theoretically and significantly point towards anomie and control.
Anomie occurs when society emphasizes achievement or culturally prescribed goals without addressing the approved norms that regulate the means to achieve those goals (Zembroski, 2011: 246). Originally, Merton identified anomie as a feature of American society in general and experienced by those in the lower socio-demographic classes because their access to legitimate opportunities are more often than not blocked (see Akers & Sellers, 2008). Nigerian social structure is unequal and unjust (Arhedo et al, 2011), and such inequality can result in anomie. The rich-poor divide obviously pressures people, especially youths from poorer backgrounds, to get involved in crimes such as armed robbery, as a way out of poverty. Whereas social systems hold the same goals for all people, they do not give the same people the equal means to achieve them. When that happens, standards of right and wrong are no longer applicable, and it is necessary to determine “which of the available procedures is most efficient in netting the culturally approved value?” (Merton, 1968: 189). The state of anomie results in “a literal demoralization, i.e., a de-institutionalization of the means” (Merton, 1968: 190; see also Zembroski, 2011: 245). For example, corruption in the higher echelons of Nigerian society appears to result in the fracturing of moral standards, and this causes problems in justifying the observance of the rule of law. This is because social structures exert enormous pressures on people to deviate (Merton, 1968). Therefore, anomie-strain theory seems to be the closest theory that can offer an explanation of criminal behaviour found among Nigerian youths in this study.
Moreover, the choice of anomie-strain theory to explain criminal behaviour in an anomic society like Nigeria is for the reason that it has a more fluid flexible fit into the Nigerian context, and explains criminal behaviour mainly from an economic position. Anomic crimes like armed robbery (Messner & Rosenfeld, 2001b) seem to flourish in Nigeria because some segments of the youth population are disenfranchised, disaffected and fairly alienated by the society and government such
that legitimate opportunities to achieve the desired cultural goals are far removed from them. The youth respondendents for this study is a typical example, hence the employment of anomie-strain theory to explain their criminal behaviour. They see themselves as bad friends, who are looking for money, and blaming the government for the poverty and deep-rooted corruption in the country. Of course, considering these criminogenic factors, it cannot be gainsaid that a state of normlessness and social disorganisation prevail in Nigeria. Society's attitudes toward corruption, cheating on one's income tax, embezzling, fraud, and interfering with the right to privacy help set the stage for acts that may be considered criminal. In Nigeria, there is a tendency to exalt the rich without bothering about the source of the wealth (Odumosu, 1999: 72). When a group of people, or society or community become more disorganized or anomic, there is the tendency that higher rate of crime and deviance could be found among them (Akers & Sellers, 2008).
Another reason for using anomie-strain theory in this study is because it provides an insight into the crime problem in Nigeria, which is arguably connected to the unbriddled quest for money. According to Alemika and Chukwuma (2001: 20), Nigerian society lays more emphasis on being “successful” in the sense of acquisition of wealth, engagement in ostentatious lifestyle and conspicuous consumption (possess expensive cars, large and expensive buildings, make huge donations at public fund- raising, etc), to be highly educated and to wield political power. Those who fail to meet these aspirations and goals prescribed by society experience tremendous pressure or strain. The main emphasis of Merton’s anomie-strain theory is “monetary success”, which is one criminogenic aspect of the content of the American Dream. As far as monetary success is an inherently open-ended and elusive, the adequacy of the legitimate means for achieving this particular cultural goal is suspect. Irrespective of the amount of money someone is able to make by staying within legal boundaries, illegal means will always offer further advantages in pursuit of the ultimate goal (Rosenfeld & Messner, 2000). It is obvious that those who may have no access to legitimate opportunities are most likely to suffer the greatest strain (Merton, 1968).
Social control theory deals with social bonds in relation to delinquency, and it helps to explain some probable factors that led the respondents to get involved in armed robbery, and complements anomie-strain theory. Hirschi (2002, [1969]) argues that when there is a strong social bond with conventional others and institutions, crime is likely not to be committed. Logically, youths who have nothing to loose socially, morally, or instrumentally are likely to become law breakers, as compared to those with strong social bonds to conventional others, institutions and belief systems (Jensen, 2000: 140). The rule of law in Nigeria is very fragile, and people are sceptical of societal laws and norms. It appears that some are able to break the law with impunity, and this may explain why corruption is endemic and a way of life.
Current theoretical criminological perspectives do not adequately take account of the Nigerian experience of crime and criminality. Therefore, there is need for the development of a Nigerian criminological framework. It is hoped that this research makes a contribution to that body of knowledge. A Nigerian criminology will take into full account an understanding of the management of crime and criminal justice in the country. It will aim at linking crime with certain issues such as: tribal differences that have formed part of the people’s lifestyle; rural-urban migration of people, especially youths in search for jobs; the use of “juju” power and belief in “God”; high levels of inequality and corruption among the powerful elite in Nigeria in relation to the lower class people. By identifying these issues, what comes next is the beginning of a debate on the development of a Nigerian criminological perspective.
Having said that, the main aim of this thesis is to study the factors responsible for the involvement of youths in armed robbery. In doing so, we will look closely at armed robbery from the perspective of offenders. The importance of studying youths and armed robbery in the Nigerian context lies in their increasing involvement in the crime, which has become a disturbing phenomenon right across the country (Federal Republic of Nigeria [FRN], 2001). Moreover, the criminal activities of Nigerian youths “are to a considerable extent products of our depressed economy, political repression and instability under military rule, and the systematic abandonment of the positive aspects of our cherished cultural values and traditions” (FRN, 2001: 17).
“Youth” is a socially constructed part of the lifespan positioned between childhood and adulthood. This definition stresses an understanding of youth having social, cultural and biological components (Hill, 2008: 167). Although “youth” is a concept that does not exist in comparable form in all societies, it remains an embodied social construct associated with young people, who “are often constructed in dominant discourses as simultaneously and paradoxically at risk, and a risk to society” (Holt, 2009: 283). At the same time, youth is considered as a key indicator of the state of a country itself. In other words, there is a generally held assumption that young people hold a key to the future of a country, hence the treatment and management of “youth” is expected to provide a means of solving the country’s problems (Griffin, 2001).
The way in which a nation defines its youth is relative to the objective conditions and realities that exist therein (FRN, 2001). Following the World Health Organisation’s (WHO) specification, youths are between 15 and 24 years of age, nevertheless, in most countries of sub-Saharan Africa, national policy extends the youth age to 30, 35 and in rare cases to age 40 (Blum, 2007 Students sharing their experience after using our serviceThis Project is for You If:
Yes, This Is My Situation — Send Me the Complete MaterialHere's everything you get with the complete project package:
See Our Conversations With Students on WhatsApp





What Other Students Are Saying
Can't find what you're looking for?
Search thousands of project topics across every department.
Related Project Materials
EVALUATING THE IMPACT OF YOUTH UNEMPLOYMENT ON THE ESCALATION OF CRIME RATES IN CAMEROON
CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION 1.1 Background of the study Youth unemployment is a widespread issue that affects countries around the world, particularly those that are still developing.…
📄 Project Material📋 54 pages👁 10,664 viewsEVALUATING THE COPING STRATEGIES UTILIZED BY UNEMPLOYED YOUTHS IN CAMEROON
CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION 1.1 Background of the study Young people hold a significant position in any society. They are among the most valuable resources any country may possess. In…
📄 Project Material📋 54 pages👁 9,223 viewsEVALUATING THE CONTRIBUTION OF THE INFORMAL SECTOR IN ALLEVIATING UNEMPLOYMENT IN CAMEROON
CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION 1.1 Background of the study The global population includes about 1.2 billion individuals between the ages of 15 and 24. Approximately 90 percent of these i…
📄 Project Material📋 54 pages👁 9,457 viewsCIVIL SERVANT PERCEPTION OF THE CAUSES AND CONSEQUENCES OF OFFICE POLITICS IN PUBLIC SERVICE OF CAMEROON
CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION Background of the Study Naturally, politics is an integral aspect of human existence and perceived by many as an inevitable aspect of society that is not i…
📄 Project Material📋 54 pages👁 9,755 viewsASSESSMENT OF THE KNOWLEDGE ON FIRE DISASTER RISK REDUCTION AMONG TRADERS IN LAGOS ISLAND MARKET, LAGOS STATE
ASSESSMENT OF THE KNOWLEDGE ON FIRE DISASTER RISK REDUCTION AMONG TRADERS IN LAGOS ISLAND MARKET, LAGOS STATE CHAPTER ONE INTRODUCTION Background of the Study The notion of risk is…
📄 Project Material📋 54 pages👁 9,458 views
See More Public Administration Final Year Research Project Topics & Materials »
