Ā
An automated trading system (ATS) is a computer trading program that automatically submits trades to an exchange, Allen, et al (2000). An example of an early ATS is Instinet which allows traders to input trades invisibly to the market, with a crossing price determined by a Volume- Weighted Average Price (VWAP); the ratio of the value traded to total volume traded over a particular time horizon (usually one day); which is a measure of the average price a stock traded at over the trading horizon. Instinet also enables anonymous conversations and negotiations to take place between bidders, and so reduces informational costs to the participants, (Jiang, et al 2001).
There are many types of ATS operations internationally, Sioud and Hmaied (2003). They include: electronic bulletin boards; other automated trade matching systems; ATS operated by overseas exchanges; broker-to-client automated linkages; and ATS operated on the Internet. New regulatory requirements have been or are being developed internationally to address ATS operations. ATS operations may provide benefits to the marketplace. Depending on the system involved, some of the potential benefits include lower costs, specialized services, ease of access, and expanded product ranges, Venkataraman, (2001). However, ATS operations may also raise concerns, such as the fitness and properness of the system operator, lack of transparency, adequacy of surveillance arrangements, and the maintenance of security and control procedures and back-up arrangements. Automated trading system forms an excellent starting point for everyone who is interested in turning the stock market opportunities into considerable profit. It provides significantly improved chances for both short and long term-profit, as it does not have any market bias, nor does it work on any of the human traits that can hamper trading, such as greed, impulsivity or fear. Whilst the benefits of automated trading system are highly beneficial in the modern stock market, investors turbulence marred by the sudden collapse of stockbroking firms more than ever before have been observed at the Nigeria stock exchange. Automated trading system is a controlled electronic Central Depository System (CDS).
This is a computer system that facilitates holding of securities in electronic accounts and facilitates faster and easier processing of transactions for NSE securities (shares and bonds).CDSC has then authorized central depository agents (CDA) who are either stockbrokers or custodian banks, to open accounts in CDS on behalf of investors. The NSE was established in 1954 as a voluntary association of stockbrokers registered under the Societiesā Act. In 1991, the NSE was registered under the Companyās Act and phased out the ācall overā trading system in favour of the floor-based Open Outcry System. On 1st august 2000, the NSE introduced a new trading cycle (T+5) and the Central Depository System (CDS) Act was passed by parliament and received presidential assent ā paving the way for the full implementation of the CDS.
The CDSC was officially launched in November 2004 to manage the CDS electronic system. After this period, the NSE has witnessed a number of massive IPOs and a significant growth in investors numbers. These include the KENGEN IPO of May 2006, Scangroup IPO of August 2006, Eveready IPO of November 2006, Nigeria-Re IPO of August 2007 and the largest of them all was the listing of 50 billion shares of Safaricom in June 2008. On Monday 11th September 2006, the NSE witnessed the implementation of live trading on the Automated trading system. Thereafter on 17th December 2007, the NSE officially implemented the Wide Area Network ( a remote trading platform based on the ATS ). In this system, stockbrokers and investment banks trade through terminals in their offices linked to the NSE trading engine via the WAN. NSE is fully owned by the nineteen licensed stockbrokers. NSE has four core stakeholders; the investors, the listed companies, and the members/brokers. The most important stakeholders in any exchange are the investors. In the case of Nigeria, the number of investors remains very small, though in the recent years substantial number of investors has been attracted to the market. The gross number of investors in all listed companies is approximately 1.5 million based on CDS accounts that have been opened as at April 30, 2008 (CDS Preliminary Report, 2008). However, despite the massive growth in investor numbers at the NSE in recent years, coupled with the listing of several large companies through IPOs, the market has also recently witnessed a gradual shift due to the collapse of several stockbrokers, loss of clientsā invested funds either through the ārogueā brokers or as a result of an extremely bearish market, etc. This sudden phenomenon came up soon after the introduction of the Automated Trading System and the Central Depository System ā both of which were perceived as better and modern replacement of the old manual certificate trading systems. It is with this notion in mind that
there clearly exists a problem ā Could the collapse of the stockbrokers be related to the introduction of the electronic automated trading system? Could it be that the various institutions entrusted with the management of these electronic trading systems may not be functioning as expected? Therein lies a challenge ā the automated trading system needs an evaluation, hence this study.
1.2Ā Statement of the ProblemThe process of buying and selling shares has undergone a fundamental transformation with the introduction of a central depository system. Previously, the buying and selling of shares was affected through transfer of share certificates. Share certificates were the mode through which an investor owned shares. This system delayed the transfer of shares, as it was necessary to cancel theĀ Ā Ā oldĀ Ā Ā certificatesĀ Ā Ā andĀ Ā Ā issueĀ Ā Ā newĀ Ā Ā Ā onesĀ Ā Ā Ā wheneverĀ Ā Ā Ā aĀ Ā Ā Ā saleĀ Ā Ā Ā wasĀ Ā Ā Ā made. The Central Depository & Settlement Corporation Limited (CDSC) commenced operations of the central depository system (CDS) in late 2004. The central depository system was commissioned as ready for use on 10th November 2004. The commissioning meant that investors who held or intended to hold shares listed on the Nigeria stock exchange were supposed to open electronic shares accounts through their stockbrokers or their custodian banks, and could henceforth trade through those accounts rather than in paper certificate form, as was previously done (CDS Preliminary Report, 2008). In the recent past, cries by investors in NSE has often been linked to poor management of fragile automated trading system by players. Confidence has declined as a result of brokers trading on investorsā shares without their consent and their collapse with investors wealth. Mukumu (2009) notes that the image of the local stock market has been battered by revelations that brokers have been manipulating client accounts and entering into transactions with their clientsā money illegally. This has violated the widely held preposition that, participation in any stock exchange is based on perceived trust, confidence, reliability, accountability, transparency and governance of brokers, NSE, and other players. But the market regulatory bodies have since appeared or perceived to have failed in their duty, therefore appearing to lose their trust and confidence among different classes of investors. It is imperative to note that the CMA has been consistently criticized for ineffectively managing and regulating the activities of stockbrokers and other market players at the NSE. Consequently, this study has been necessitated by the need to examine, evaluate and appraise the challenges, the perceived gains and losses of the automated trading system at the Nigeria stock exchange. A few
studies have been conducted on automated trading systems. In Nigeria, Kamau (2007) examined the impact of stock exchange automation on volume, volatility & liquidity on stocks at the NSE. However, Kamauās study did not focus on the overall effects of automation to the market. This will serve as a springboard to undertake this research. This research will attempt to evaluate the overall performance of the automation of trading at the Nigeria stock exchange.
1.3Ā Research ObjectivesThe main objective of this study will be to assess and appraise the perception of the MBA students with regard to the automated trading system being used at the Nigeria stock exchange. The study will be guided by the following specific objectives:-
i.Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā To establish the level of investors satisfaction with the Automated Trading System.
ii.Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā To assess and analyze the perceived advantages and limitations associated with the introduction of the ATS at the NSE.
1.4Ā Research questioni. What is the level of investors satisfaction with the Automated Trading System ?
ii. What is the perceived advantages and limitations associated with the introduction of the ATS at the NSE ?
1.5Ā Significance of the studyThe proposed study will be of great importance to various market stakeholders, namely academicians, scholars, investors, NSE board and also the CMA. The researcher will benefit from scholarly materials by other authors for successful completion of the proposed study. Similarly, the study upon successful completion will add to the existing body of knowledge on Automated Trading System being used currently at the NSE. This will be useful for future scholars on the subject. The study findings will also be of importance to both institutional and individual investors in the country. The study will identify the level of investorsā satisfaction with Automated Trading System, the level of trust on institutions entrusted with the management of the ATS in Nigeria, and the perceived benefits and limitations associated with the introduction of theĀ Ā ATSĀ Ā atĀ Ā theĀ Ā NSE. These will consequently help investors make prudent and informed investment decisions. The board of the NSE would also benefit from the results of this evaluation of the Automated Trading System (ATS) in Nigeria, and probably take note of some of the critical points that may arise out of the study. The regulatory board ( CMA ) would also benefit immensely with the information of whether the institutions entrusted with the management of the ATS in Nigeria are trusted by the investing public or not, and for what possible reasons.
1.6 Scope ofĀ the study
The study will focus on the impact of automated system on Nigerian stock exchange. The study is to determine the role of the stock market in the economic development of the country through the use of Automated Trading System (ATS), which replaced the use of Cal-over mode on the position' of Automated Trading System which is in savings and capital formulation.
1.7 Limitation of study
Finance,inadequate materials and time constraint were the challenges the researchers encountered during the course of the study.





